Welcome to Olympic City!

You’re in the right place!  We are a husband and wife team who LOVE this business and love doing good work for good people.  We’re believe in the face-to-face version of this business built and not the one that hides behind websites and fake five star reviews.

As a husband-and-wife team we’ve been in and around the home business for over thirty years.  And because of that, we can’t possibly convey all of that experience in a few mouse clicks.  Reach out.  Connect.  Come see us at one of the home shows.  We are quietly one of the fastest growing renovation companies in Calgary and look forward to hearing about your project large or small. Just FYI, EVERY contractors bread and butter are smaller projects so don’t hesitate to reach out.

[instagram-feed feed=1]

LP SmartSide vs James Hardie: Which Is Better for Calgary Homes?

Exterior Renovations

LP SmartSide vs James Hardie: The Real Comparison

If you’re looking at premium siding for your Calgary home, you’re probably comparing LP SmartSide (engineered wood) and James Hardie (fiber cement). Both are excellent choices. Here’s how they actually compare.

Quick Summary

Factor LP SmartSide James Hardie
Material Engineered wood Fiber cement
Cost (installed) $10 – $15 / sq ft $12 – $18 / sq ft
Lifespan 30-50 years 30-50 years
Warranty 5-year labour, 50-year substrate 30-year limited
Weight Lighter (easier to install) Heavier
Hail Resistance Good Excellent
Fire Rating Class C Class A
Installation Faster More labour-intensive

n

⚠ Estimate Disclaimer: These are only ROUGH estimates that can vary wildly. Do not take these numbers as gospel. Having a defined scope of work and exact selections will give you clarity.

LP SmartSide Deep Dive

LP SmartSide is engineered wood treated with SmartGuard (a proprietary moisture and termite protection). It looks more like real wood than fiber cement does.

Pros

  • Lower cost than Hardie (15-20% savings)
  • Lighter — easier and faster to install
  • More realistic wood grain appearance
  • Strong warranty on the substrate
  • More forgiving for contractors to install

Cons

  • Wood-based — needs proper sealing/painting
  • Class C fire rating (vs Class A for Hardie)
  • Newer product — less long-term Calgary field data

James Hardie Deep Dive

James Hardie fiber cement has been the premium standard in Calgary for 20+ years. It’s a concrete-like material that looks like wood siding.

Pros

  • Class A fire rating (highest)
  • Best hail resistance in Calgary
  • Proven track record in Calgary climate
  • Holds paint 2-3x longer than wood siding
  • Won’t rot, warp, or attract pests
  • ColorPlus factory finishes (15-year paint warranty)

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost
  • Heavier — requires skilled installation
  • Specialty cutting tools required
  • More expensive repairs

Cost Comparison for a Typical Calgary Home

Home Size LP SmartSide Total James Hardie Total
1,500 sq ft (bungalow) $15,000 – $22,500 $18,000 – $27,000
2,000 sq ft (2-storey) $20,000 – $30,000 $24,000 – $36,000
2,500 sq ft (larger home) $25,000 – $37,500 $30,000 – $45,000

n

⚠ Estimate Disclaimer: These are only ROUGH estimates that can vary wildly. Do not take these numbers as gospel. Having a defined scope of work and exact selections will give you clarity.

Our Recommendation

Choose LP SmartSide if: Budget is a primary factor, you want the most realistic wood look, or your installer has more SmartSide experience.

Choose James Hardie if: You want the absolute best hail and fire performance, you plan to own the home long-term, or you’re in an area with higher fire risk.

For most Calgary homes, both are excellent choices. You can’t go wrong — just make sure installation quality is top-notch.

Ready to Choose?

Related Articles

Pillar Guide: Exterior Renovations Calgary: The Complete Guide

Planning your renovation? Start with our complete Calgary renovation guide.

Contact Olympic City Renovations for a free consultation.

Olympic City Renovations serves Calgary, Priddis, Okotoks, and surrounding communities.